Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipster favorite concept album Watertown lately. Having seen the guy's career highlight movies and been duly impressed but hardly wowed by the Chairman of the Board's prowess as an actor, I decided to check out one of his more obscure starring vehicles. I'm so glad I did! The Detective is truly an odd movie: it encompasses not one but two police cases from act to solution, feeling less like a film than a few episodes of today's prestige TV tossed back in time to make a fascinatingly uneasy fit with its era. While Clint Eastwood and Charles Bronson were helping WW2-vet dads across the nation reconsider their opposition to fascism, here's Frank Sinatra in a terrific role as a hard-bitten career cop who realizes as he climbs the ladder that it's impossible to be both a police officer and a good man.
The highlights of this movie are the moments that make America's lack of social progress since 1968 glaringly obvious: while our civil society still dithers over whether homophobia and racist extrajudicial killings by the police are Bad, Actually, Sinatra plays an ultimate he-man with no time for that kind of bullshit, a chad who makes sure the chuds he's surrounded by see that there's no light at the end of that tunnel, just an implacable foe with clenched fists, a loaded gun, and moral certainty on his side. It'd be bracing to see this kind of basic respect for humanity in any movie from this era (plenty of cool-guy hippie movies had a lot less time for "fags" than this resolutely square cop movie does); seeing it coming from Frank Sinatra, the ultimate image of stoic, whitebread postwar masculinity is head-spinning.
Guys like this were out there, though: my own father grew up surrounded by them in union-liberal Detroit, and that's probably the main reason I didn't turn out a total fuckface myself. I gotta imagine assholes from Pete Hegseth down the totem pole of based mascs through Andrew Tate worship Sinatra: seeing him perform human decency and understanding as a tough job that requires a tough man to do it defuses all the contemporary arguments for a masculinity that requires toxicity better than any other single piece of media I can think of. There's a resonance with Watertown here- that album bombed because it sees Sinatra deep in character as a ruminative, ruined no-hope single dad, pining fruitlessly for the absent wife he can't even muster the strength to send a letter to, his usual hard-won triumphalism completely eluding him this time, and this movie depicts him as a cop whose toughness is made necessary because of his softness, his care for others and refusal to let an uncaring system beat it out of him.
Journeyman director Gordon Douglas turns in a stylish movie full of beautiful, utilitarian couture, NYC locations that don't usually make the silver screen and feel all the more lived in for their unfamiliarity, and solidly mounted scenes that juggle a sprawling cast full of terrific actors (Robert Duvall as Sinatra's opposite number, a detective too bigoted to be competent; Lee Remmick, every inch Sinatra's equal as his estranged nympho wife). Douglas directed no less than 92 movies in his career, and acted in quite a few more- whatever the film equivalent of Stephen King's graphomania is, this guy had it. Where Roderick Thorp's source novel braids its multiple whodunnits together into aspects of a single, overarching case, Douglas just decides he loves making movies so much that he'll shove two of them into a single runtime, using an episodic structure and character notes that carry over the whole film to make it feel as whole as he can.
I can't really say it works too well: this has rising action, but it definitely lacks a climax, with the excitement coming and going as the days tick by. What we end up with is something that feels like an honest look at the daily life of a '60s cop show protagonist, too sensational and glamorous to be real but too downbeat and procedural for fantasy. The fulcrum at the center of this whirling merry go round is, well, Frank Sinatra, in a performance that might not be his best, but exerts far more gravity than any other role I've seen him in. Holding a story this overstuffed and a cast of this many great actors doing very different things together as the single, unerring throughline is seriously impressive. I've read that Sinatra, disdaining modern audiophile recording techniques, liked to do his vocal takes in the middle of a big room, surrounded by the orchestra and cutting his voice loose at full register to make himself heard, riding the energy and thrust of true performance to push himself to excellence. He does a similar thing here, with similar results, bringing a truly weird movie home with casual grace.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Detective (1968)
Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...
-
- PSYCHOPATH VS. AUTIST: The Final Battle For The Vanishing Mind Of America (Slowed/Bass Boosted) - ELIZABETH HOLMES is guilty as sin:...
-
In both this and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - the two good Batman Animated movies - the Joker creates a queer-coded chosen family ...
-
“You’ve spoken so often of ending it all. I can’t understand why this should be so difficult for you.” An understated, plainspoken movi...
No comments:
Post a Comment