Friday, November 6, 2026

Eyes Wide Shut (1999)

What better time than this Very Epstein Christmas we're having to rewatch Kubrick's dizzying final statement? Like a couple of my other favorite movies (Andrei Rublev, Blade Runner, Apocalypse Now), I think it's more or less impossible to write a comprehensive critical review of this one - Tim Kreider's masterful "Introducing Sociology" comes closest, and is probably my favorite piece of movie writing ever. I'm happy to just float along in Kreider's wake and add little tidbits of my own as I go. Similar to the Epstein stuff, there's simply more to this film than I think anyone can really account for: you'd go insane if you really tried to chase down every thread and connect all the dots.

You know who else had a mental health crisis caused by this movie? Tom Cruise! I've mined this ground before in my own best piece of movie writing on Vanilla Sky, but going from a cult whose purpose is the total elimination of compulsive behavior to the all-time longest continuous movie shoot in history, as helmed by Stanley "we're gonna do 75 takes of every shot" Kubrick cannot have been a fun transition for Cruise, who despite his entanglement with a group of motherfuckers who've gotten away with some insane shit in their time, is ultimately a rather simple fellow. People talk a lot more about Kubrick's sadistic destruction of Shelley Duvall's ego during the Shining shoot, but he's up to a similar trick with the world's biggest movie star here. Watching this you almost have to conclude that breaking down such a meticulously constructed persona, and the equally artificial psyche behind it, was part of the fun for its director.

Kubrick surrounds Cruise, the product of an abusive father and a broken home, with a cast full of directors: the maestro Sydney Pollack (himself a former Cruise director), the future hotshot Todd Field, and a great who never was, Leon Vitali, whose work as Kubrick's AD involved more labor and expertise than a lot of filmmakers with their names above the title ever bring. Cruise, who never met a power structure he could hide his awe of, is visibly folding in on himself all movie, surrounded on all sides by forces he can't beat or even fight, but must simply exist beneath- a neat summary of the film's story as well as the conditions its director created for its star.

Adding insult to injury, Kubrick makes more than anyone else ever did out of the is-he-or-isn't-he gay innuendo that persistently followed Cruise for the first half of his career, defining Bill Harford's medical profession as solely the province of men who can play with a beautiful woman's tits without getting a boner. The sexy-sexy, dudey-dudey college bromance he reignites with Nick Nightingale (who'll "play with anybody") the instant they lock eyes is the true catalyst for the crisis of sexuality Harford experiences - fruity ass Alan Cumming can see it plainly even if Cruise can't. The most erotic images of any man this movie offers take place in Dr. Bill's imagination, after all: is he fixating on his wife's body, so shortly after the movie opens with her rebuking him for not even looking at it - or that of the handsome Naval officer with the supernatural power to end his marriage with a single glance?

And sorry but you're wrong, I'm not reading too much into this. By the end of his life, Kubrick was certainly aware of the Room 237-obsessive level of analysis superfans were bringing into the cinema for his works, and in his last movie he created a true symbol book, something oddly like an evil version of Jodorowsky's The Holy Mountain, a mystic tour of the powers behind the curtain who rule the world, in which the text overflows with so much visual and literary rhyme that the potential critical readings are nearly infinite. Kreider rightly mentions how the "uniquely provincial" NYC media complained about the inaccuracy of Kubrick's British soundstage version of their city: you gotta be the kind of moron they only make in New York to miss that he's doing it on purpose, drowning his character in massive neon words, each a potential clue, as Bill reaches a heightened, hyper-aware state of total paranoia. Names in the background tip you off about the director's intentions: BOWMAN, VITALI. Soon you too are wondering about the significance of every chip in the mosaic. Let's take the newsstand on Wren Street for example: no such street exists, but could it be a reference to Christopher Wren, the master architect and Freemason of the highest order? Alan Moore got a whole conspiracy theory book out of that guy! Or could it be the wren's traditional association with bad luck and violent death? Is Harford just a "bird in a cage"?

Like I said, you can drive yourself nuts trying to follow all this stuff, and never find a bottom to it anyhow. Kubrick creates a world soaked in words, images, allusions, pregnant pauses, and then shows us just enough for us to see it's being manipulated by forces much higher up the ladder than we can know. This is the plot of all his mature-period movies: a man enters into ego-annihilating contact with his betters, via some proscribed social ritual. It could be exploration (2001), imprisonment (Clockwork Orange), marriage (Barry Lyndon), employment (The Shining), or military conscription (Full Metal Jacket)- but in all cases the man's experience is subject to rigid institutional controls.

Eyes Wide Shut locates another field where ego death and transcendence are both in play, but one where the levers of social control are much weaker: the erotic. It is an exploration of how the purity of eroticism, a source of pleasure, freedom, and regeneration, is bound, brought to heel, and reshaped into an instrument of control by capital. Unlike Kubrick's earlier movies - the sci-fi epic, the crime-does-not-pay thriller, the picaresque, the slasher flick, the war pic - the erotic movie lacks a strong, socially proscribed narrative arc that can be followed or disrupted. It can extend long enough to end with an orgasm, or not, and that's it. This one doesn't; like a true connoisseur of pleasure, it opts for prolonging the process over reaching an explosive climax. Nothing really happens in this movie, because its characters choose for nothing to happen. Remaking the world in the name of pleasure over capital sounds great, but now that we know everyone in charge is an evil sexual deviant, where could we begin? There's just too much to deal with, and the way things are is just too comfortable. The thing about being woke is that you gotta go back to sleep at some point.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...