Friday, November 6, 2026

Giant (1956)

People laugh when I say Oakland California's finest, George Stevens, is my pick for the greatest American filmmaker; unfortunately I am right and they (you!) are wrong! The big knock on Stevens is basically that he's cheesy as hell - even when his stories are sharp and tight, with unexpected or subversive points to make, his style - visually masterful though it may be - leaves nothing to the imagination, putting a big ten-gallon Stetson hat on every element that fills the screen. Maybe so, but look a little longer.

The little movies that nibbled at the corners of the box office while Stevens raked in dough with his populist studio epics - the film noirs and early European arthouse movies - set out to teach the world a lesson that's become so ingrained it basically doesn't bear mentioning these days. We expect the movie camera to reveal Psychology, to complicate and even contradict what is plainly stated by spoken dialogue and actors' body language with Dramatic Ambiguity. We want movies to be more than what they seem, we want to see that ambiguity right in front of our eyes... in a big Stetson hat if possible, the better to write Letterbox reviews about.

George Stevens movies do not do this. Instead of Psychology, Stevens' camera reveals Character. It underlines rather than complicates the goals and actions of his characters, and the themes of his films. A good man who will be corrupted by oil wealth is literally painted black by spurting crude when he hits his first gusher. A husband and wife's reconciliation after months apart is narrated by a priest intoning the wedding ceremony they attend, as the camera drifts into a close-up of their softening faces. A small boy who will grow up to abdicate his place as a cattle-ranching land baron for life as a country doctor screams bloody murder and cries torrents of tears when placed upon a pony's back; he quiets instantly when he returns to his toy stethoscope. That's Movies for Babies, you fans of Cinema howl; but I'd say the fairer criticism is that it's a fundamentally conservative approach, right-wing even. Stevens' camera judges people by their actions, not their circumstance, and forecasts their futures with total certainty from there. Rather than a painter, Stevens is a cartoonist, giving familiar types such insistent emphasis that they come to bear the weight of symbolism.

But I mean, come on. This man filmed the US Army's liberation of the concentration camps at Dachau, Buchenwald, and Belsen; perhaps he was correct to see some value in a movie camera simply stating things as they seem! Stevens' three best films, the postwar American Trilogy of A Place in the Sun, Shane, and Giant, take at face value the proposition that the USA is founded not on the divine right of kings, but on each man's rightness in doing what he feels best. The only true sin is for one to violate another's freedom to walk his own path. With a land full of people moving in straight lines from birth through destiny to goal, someone gets stepped on every minute; Stevens frames such conflict as inevitable, and thus strangely blameless. Stevens' camera, in short, shows us nothing more or less than manifest destiny, in movies about exactly that.

Only racism and sexism, institutionalized checks on individual freedom, are roundly condemned in Giant. People's individual actions, as racist sexist protagonist Jordan Benedict II proclaims, are "just one of those things." The only time the conflict stops is in Stevens' many scenes of ritual, when community is made real by agreed-upon submission to a common master, be it God or Nation. A wedding scene; a state funeral, with the ritual's text always filmed in full, before the squabbling begins again. Stevens paints America both as it sees itself and as it is; everybody else is just choosing one side or the other of a two-sided coin.

First big screen watch, with my mom at a matinee where I was the youngest person in the audience by ohhhh say 25 years? And I'm old!

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...