Scorsese, in the era of MTV's cultural peak, innovates the motion picture as DJ set. Because of who made it and who's in it, I feel like the reality of what this movie is gets obscured: it's not some classicist pre-Hays code Jimmy Cagney gangster opera, it's steroidal '80s action blow-em-up filmmaking meets music video editing, indelibly of its time and simply put together well enough to come away as lasting art.
Like any good dancefloor maestro, Scorsese keeps the BPM steady and sticks to a recognizable genre core, returning frequently and successfully to recurring banger motifs - Pesci losing his shit, DeNiro as replacement for an abusive father, Bracco losing her shit. The moments of real dramatic tension where you're moved to kind of care about the characters in this function a lot like samples - trapped inside the unstoppable momentum of Thelma Schoonmaker's kick-drum editing, you go hey, I know this song! A refrain or riff that might make you feel something when you listen to it in its original context simply adds an edge to the forward momentum here, keeping your eyes open amid the rhythmic bludgeoning.
There's so much this movie doesn't have: character arcs, setup and payoff, visual beauty, chemistry between actors, dramatic stakes, even a plot, really. This is the movie version of Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns, something rendered in a more or less experimental form that's pulled off so masterfully it immediately became its own cliche, and provided the coming generation with a set of straight-up replacements for the craft-based solutions that earlier makers had used to get their artworks over. But there's nothing in this that doesn't work, that's why what it's missing doesn't matter. You could really only add to it by subtraction: I'd love to see a version of Goodfellas with the music and Ray Liotta's narration stripped out - don't get me wrong, both are great - but I feel like that'd end up as a cross between the Godfather and Bresson or something. This might have been so influential that its crazy form feels normal now, but the raw material it traffics in is still pretty much beyond reproach.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Detective (1968)
Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...
-
- PSYCHOPATH VS. AUTIST: The Final Battle For The Vanishing Mind Of America (Slowed/Bass Boosted) - ELIZABETH HOLMES is guilty as sin:...
-
In both this and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - the two good Batman Animated movies - the Joker creates a queer-coded chosen family ...
-
“You’ve spoken so often of ending it all. I can’t understand why this should be so difficult for you.” An understated, plainspoken movi...

No comments:
Post a Comment