Friday, November 6, 2026

Grizzly Man (2005)

I don't know enough about pre-agricultural civilizations to be sure, but my guess is that a guy like Tim Treadwell wouldn't be considered such an anomaly had he lived a few millennia ago. There's so much post-humanism in our lives these days, how can anyone rebuke the opposing urge to be pre-human, or trans-human, to embrace one's inner spirit as separate from one's biology and live one's inner truth? Treadwell is in so many ways an ideal American, a rugged individualist who cast off polite society's rules to live as an ubermensch, but rather than overmastering his environment with brute force, sought to subsume himself in it, to become one with the perfect circle that is the unspoiled natural ecosystem. It's pretty hard to deny he succeeded; 13 years as a prey animal among apex predators is a real respectable run.

Herzog's movies are always moral accountings of some kind or other and by any human standard, Treadwell died in debt, owing the world the life of Amie Huguenard and of the bear who killed them both. In the moral world Treadwell gave everything he was to become a part of, though, such equations don't exist, and there's no blame for anything. Maybe the most profound truth this movie locates is that humans have come too far to melt back into the forest with the birds and beasts. Where we walk, our world comes with us. Wherever we go, there we are.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...