Friday, November 6, 2026

It's a Wonderful Life (1946)

OK, here we go. Watched on the silver screen for the first time, somehow, a few days before Christmas at the local Oakland co-op theater with my sister home for the holidays after years and years away. We've done this one every Christmas since we were maybe 4 or 5, and the understanding - the recognition - has come in waves. I remember being shattered as a teen by the weakness of George's protestations that he wants to do what HE wants to do. Shattered as a newly married 25 year old by "Welcome home, Mr. Bailey". Shattered as a newly divorced 27 year old by the "Christmas present from a very good friend of mine". Now shattered in my early 30s by the second act from top to bottom - I moved back to my home town, bought a house, got a dog, work a job I hate, blast away my nighttime hours trying to do what *I* want to do. "It's deep in the race..."

From one Catholic boy to another, Frank Capra, you rendered the American Christ. We're all George Bailey because this is just what happens in America, we too live with his sufferings like uninvited guests, and if anything pulls us up from that dreadful moment when we lose faith in our ability to keep going, it's others' faith in us, our seeing them in the same boat, and their ability to repay our sacrifice with sacrifice of their own. This is a message that strikes like a gunshot to the heart of everything else movies teach you about how to be a man in this country, that shoots down and shatters Shane and Dirty Harry and Batman and Indiana Jones and Rocky and the Man with No Name, because this is true when all those are made up: You can't stand alone because nobody can. It's only black hats and supervillains who hiss to us in poisoned whispers that it's glorious to try.

Every year I purge myself with this movie, I feel myself borne up and suspended over the awful boiling cauldron of one man's life that is impossible not to recognize one's own in, feel my emotions clatter through peaks and valleys that only grow more powerful each time for being so familiar, so well remembered. When this movie makes me cry, at this point it's as much for myself and everyone else as for George; for my past and present and future and the echoes of emotion from all of them this story stirs. "You once called me a warped, frustrated old man! What are you but a warped, frustrated young man?"

The yearly repetition, the agony, the awe, the catharsis, the infinite depths within a very simple tale I've known from top to bottom since before I can remember. This movie is my Christmas Mass, as religious an experience as anything I've ever had. Nothing compares.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...