Friday, November 6, 2026

Satantango (1994)

A summary in emojis:

🐄 🔔😒💸🐷🌧️👮‍♂️🍷🚶‍♂️🐈🙀⚰️💃🪗🛞🏰🦉💸🍲🇭🇺🍸🔕◼️

Me watching ts: 😵‍💫

Any review of this 432-minute monster has to be as much about one's experience watching it as the movie itself... but that's every review of every movie, yanno? Anyhow - beautiful 35mm print struck from the original camera negative in a sold out crowd at the legendary Pacific Film Archive - a place that's usually an AARP stronghold but this night hosted a really young, super engaged crowd. Cinema's not dead just cause they don't make good movies anymore! This showing was broken up with 2 intermissions, one after chapters 1-3 and the next after chapters 4-6. I appreciated the breaks, I needed a beer or 5 and my sandwich at some point, but I'm not sure they were ideally placed. The unremitting tedium of chapter 3, "Know Something", in which a gigantic fat dude spends an hour-plus struggling from home to the liquor store to refill his jug, did not make for a compelling cliffhanger!

My simplistic, reductive characterization of Tarr for people who haven't seen any of his is "evil Andrei Tarkovsky" - I love the hypnotic way both artists submerge you in a world different than our own, sealing its surface over your head and massaging you into living through their eyes and emotions for a couple hours. Tarr takes his time doing that in this one, but he gets there eventually, and when he does, yeah, it is evil Tarkovsky man! A weather-sodden, age-destroyed Slavic world where ordinary ignoramuses gut their way through a day's drudgery - but in Tarr it's unrelieved by the divine grace, the spectacle of the transcendent that so enraptures Tarkovsky. It's just slogging though the muck, dealing with the reality of a world abandoned by God. I don't think this is Tarr's best movie, but it's certainly the most exhaustive reading of his thesis, his artistic image, and it contains so much beautifully bleak photography of apocalyptic landscapes thick with shades of mist and charcoal that it's impossible not to see what he means. To feel he's referring to something real.

Tarr's rep, and the rep of this 7+ hour black and white subtitled movie about depression and alcoholism among collective farmers, obviously precedes the work itself... I came in ready to suffer, forgetting how my man can be a pretty dynamic filmmaker when he needs to. For an artsy museum piece, there are many, many scenes of drunken shitheads going beast mode on each other in this, stuff that would no doubt raise a snicker in the Farrelly Brothers or Mark Twain. It's not all one thing, it's a master filmmaker worming through tons of different cinematic modes like a snake shedding skin, finding the perfect container for each moment before exhausting it.

Like Damnation, Satantango kicks off with the vague outline of a crime thriller: tough guys arguing over money, the town slattern sneaking into bed after bed behind her husband's back, the police clamping down to figure out what's going on, and a mysterious figure noting every character's precise movements. From there it becomes a Western, with ordinary townsfolk in a wasteland abandoned by civilization attempting to create their own luck with livestock theft and upping sticks to homestead in a grand, abandoned ranch. It tips into cosmic horror in chapter 5, the infamous "cat torture" sequence, which would absolutely make a top-10 horror film if presented on its own the way chapters of Kieslowski's Dekalog are sometimes shown. And the back half is Soviet Realism turned against itself, a biting, nuanced, ultra-bitter political allegory about the failed promises made to a backward populace by Warsaw Pact Communism.

Honestly, the political aspect of this movie cheapens it a tad for me. I'm not taking the work on its own terms here, but when so many of Tarr's (much) shorter films reach for and actually capture something grander - desire and emptiness, God and the Void - seeing him gnawing at such length on something so specific feels... small, somehow. Perhaps unworthy of such ridiculously grand scope. And yet it's once the political metaphor starts powering the story of these townsfolk's doomed attempt at anarchosyndicalism that the movie really comes to life, turns legitimately dynamic and exciting. I said to someone walking out at the end that this was the only Tarr movie I'd seen that took place in more than one location, and that was about more than one thing haha - it's because he's talking about his own life! The blood beating in the veins of of his countrymen! You can't blame a guy so passionate about darkness for getting a little carried away when discussing the tragic history of his own nation.

Who gives a fuck about farmers in Hungary, sure, but who gives a fuck about anything or anyone? Bela Tarr, Mr. Nihilistic Cinema himself, that's who. If divine inspiration leavens Tarkovsky, gives him his wings, Tarr is borne up by a purely human urge not to let the tiny, ruined lives of those around him pass by without being documented. The film ends with the sedentary drunk who's spent all movie desperately in search of a refill returning to his archive of notes that exhaustively detail the minute doings of his neighbors, nailing boards over his windows, and resuming his chronicle in total darkness. That's Tarr at work, and that he can illuminate the black for us with a projector's light is a miracle.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...