Massive credit for finally, after 25 years of nonstop superhero movies, taking the backstory as read and going in media res. This isn't "universe building" or "myth making", thank god - the universe is built, Trump is a bigger national mythopoetic demigod figure than any comic book character will ever be, and James Gunn wades in like he's starting a new storyarc on issue #158 of an ongoing series. This lacks the overexplained spoon-feeding of concepts that are no more difficult or outlandish than anything you see in any other action-sci-fi movies- it doesn't apologize for being based on a comic book. It's got some balls!
Gunn makes missteps- none of the jokeyjokes are actually funny - but the tone he establishes is pretty much dead on. This is a romp, lighthearted and sweet and charming, with just enough salt in the stew (Metamorpho crying!) to give it some stakes. Everything before the title sequence is just incredible, ripped right from the pages of Frank Quitely's all-time best modern superhero comics, bright and sparkling with true faith in these concepts' appeal and a real sense of wonder.
David Corenswet, holy cow - I had never even heard of this guy and he absolutely nails it. Maybe the American psyche has finally just come back around to embracing how being kinda dorky can be kinda cool, I dunno, but there's a huge part of Superman's appeal that every filmmaker since Richard Donner has been very clearly ashamed of- maybe because the memories of getting stuffed into their locker are too vivid. Gunn and Corenswet render their hero as the star quarterback who sits at the lunch table with the special needs kid because he knows he just doesn't have to worry about anybody pulling his card. They can't win the game without him! Corenswet's sweet smile at the end when Lois finally tells him she loves him too is an all-time great moment for the character, not just on film but anywhere. A wrinkle to this guy I hadn't seen before, delivered perfectly. It's beautiful.
It's when that human element, and the performances of some pretty-damn-good actors, go missing that this movie founders. Gunn's refreshing ability to do without the endless world-building and expository dialogue sequences that bog down these things' runtime really points up the one lame-ass element of superhero movies that he does embrace, the grueling CGI action sequence. Has a good action filmmaker ever made a comic book movie? The one halfway-point banger in Dark Knight is the only good superhero fight scene on film, and that's all practical effects- cars and guns. There are three big set pieces in this that absolutely freeze the movie's momentum in its tracks, and if Gunn is able to make them comprehensible they're still visually ugly and unforgivably bloated, the movie equivalent to the funniest comic book cover of all time, utterly lacking in drama or gravity. When Martin Scorsese talks about superhero movies as theme park rides, these are the parts he means: they suck the hard-earned life and meaning right off the screen. It's to Gunn's credit that his movie recovers itself after each one, but man stop doing these!
Hard to say anything interesting about the "political" "allegory" in this, which was simply lucky to be in the right place at the right time- if Black Adam was out now people would be saying the same things about it. If you are looking to Time Warner Inc. to validate your personal politics you need therapy and a long ass camping trip with no wifi, but I'll repeat something that the political mentor of mine who's deepest in the trenches told me when I complained about how the Black Bloc would play shit like Rihanna's "We Found Love" on the sound truck instead of Mac Dre or Op Ivy when we showed up to fight the Proud Boys or the other assholes or the other assholes: if you're gonna demand the impossible, you gotta take your moments of media solace where you find them, no matter if the vehicle is imperfect. If this movie had the courage of its convictions, would it actually put what genocide looks like onscreen? Yes. Is it stupid that I have to type that sentence into a review of a Superman movie? Absolutely. Did I throw the devil horns when Green Lantern knocks the Israeli tanks off their treads with a giant green plasma middle finger? You already know!
I hadn't gone to a superhero movie in the theater since Dark Knight 3; I prefer to consume dumbass comic book shit in its medium of origin, and the existence of billion-dollar franchises based on legal loopholes that allowed working-class artists to sign their rights away for a 1938-ass paycheck to keep their families in baloney sandwiches is completely unconscionable. But hey, DC got shamed into doing right by Joe Shuster and Jerry Siegel 50 years ago when it was actually possible to shame a corporation, and everything sucks nowadays anyway. It shouldn't be some hot take to just choose to enjoy the movies you watch, and I walked out of this one smiling ear to ear.
Friday, November 6, 2026
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Detective (1968)
Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...
-
- PSYCHOPATH VS. AUTIST: The Final Battle For The Vanishing Mind Of America (Slowed/Bass Boosted) - ELIZABETH HOLMES is guilty as sin:...
-
In both this and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - the two good Batman Animated movies - the Joker creates a queer-coded chosen family ...
-
“You’ve spoken so often of ending it all. I can’t understand why this should be so difficult for you.” An understated, plainspoken movi...

No comments:
Post a Comment