Friday, November 6, 2026

The Watermelon Woman (1996)

Unbelievably good! This movie's big gambit, presenting its filmmaker in a faux-documentarian quest for information about a fictional early Black film star, is something that inevitably puts me, the cartoonist, in mind of comic books. Given that medium's beginnings as an undervalued trash form with droves of completely forgotten releases, this exact kind of story is not at all uncommon: an artist presents themselves, or a version thereof, as the discoverer of some lost great work and traces its history to an uneasy conclusion that speaks to a present condition. One of my all-time least favorite cartoonists, the annoyingly mononymous "Seth", made his bones the same year Watermelon Woman came out with a book called "It's a Good Life if You Don't Weaken", whose story is more or less the exact same thing as this movie's (but wack as hell where this is amazing).

I think comics does this kind of story because of a weird residual shame and confusion about the origin of the form: when your parents are disreputable and poorly remembered, there's a great temptation to simply invent some more appropriate forebears for yourself. Film doesn't really have the same problem: there's always been money in it, it's diligently maintained a sense of its own history, and there's a big menu of early greats to choose from as providers of first principles. That being said, a queer Black woman is definitely in the same boat as the comic book makers; who the hell is Cheryl Dunye supposed to look to as a model, DW Griffith?

This movie absolutely bathes in the joy of inventing a more appropriate history than the one already written, with Dunye glorying in her own skill at mocking up the artifacts of a long-forgotten past. The long, simmering scenes of Cheryl and her lesbian buddies working at the video store read like a riposte to another low-budget mid-'90s phenomenon, Clerks: where Kevin Smith's Jersey bros prop up the counter with retail existentialism that bemoans their lack of an identity, a few miles away in Philly Cheryl and Tamara are engaging in the same labor in order to build themselves an identity. Dunye has the same easy way with her actors as Smith: even when they're flubbing lines in the best take anyone was able to get, these characters feel lived in, comfortable in their own personal discomforts. Somebody not taking the recommendations they asked you for, someone else singing awful karaoke, getting kicked out of a library for taking pictures: Dunye effortlessly locates the drama in real life, so that when the big chords of love and race and belonging come down, they feel completely earned.

Putting Camille Paglia in your movie delivering critical analysis of your made-up historical findings while maintaining that she's basically Black because she's Italian is both an ungodly flex and one of the funniest things I've ever seen in my life. Trust an Oaklander who went to Michigan State to make a classic!

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...