Friday, November 6, 2026

I'll Be Gone in the Dark (2020)

The first half of this is straight fire, close to as good as it gets for true crime. Beginning as a typical bored-white-women-turn-to-crime-solving time filler, the story meanders its way into real depth, with its relentless focus on the experiences of the Golden State Killer's early rape victims before, during, and after their encounters acting as a nice corrective to the talking heads who pop up to remind you how this serial killer right here racked up some serious stats! (Stephen A Smith voice: if you CONSIDA the Golden State Killa's passa rating next to Ted Bundy's, you can see that THIS BROTHA is the PATRICK MAHOMES of murda!) There's a moment midway through this where the as-yet unknown killer's chronicler Michelle McNamara is speculating on his psychology and how it impacted that of his victims and their families, that is truly haunting, that really makes you feel something unusual and dark.

It's tempting to wonder how much better this would've been if McNamara hadn't suddenly died, stranding the series without its authorial voice halfway through; and if the man at its center hadn't been caught via 23 and Me (lol), forcing this genuinely incisive narrative into the righteous, reactionary posture of every other true crime series. Michelle McNamara might have been a better writer and a more empathetic thinker than the average slophound true crime author, but her "Letter to an Old Man" that closes the book this is based on and forms the rhetorical linchpin of the show, fantasizing about the fear the killer will feel on the day he's finally caught, is a perfect window into the moral dead end all true crime finally arrives at. At bottom, this genre is a vehicle for fantasies of righteous punishment, with actual pain and violence as their fuel.

Punishment is never righteous, though. If you truly believe the American carceral system is morally wrong, Joe DeAngelo doesn't deserve the suffering that it's designed to deliver any more than a kid with a bag of weed does, because the deliverer of that suffering holds no moral right to its delivery. Check out the victim who gives a seething impact statement in court, openly stating that he hopes DeAngelo is raped in prison every day for the rest of his life: here's a guy who's clearly learned a lot from his ordeal! True crime doesn't showcase the fabled "right role" for the police and the prison system that even some ACAB-ers will tell you it does: it shows how the noblest impulse those institutions can possibly serve is the wish for someone else to experience one's own suffering. Real evolved shit! (DeAngelo was a career cop, by the way.) There's something to be said for this show: it takes something well put together indeed to point up the limitations of its own form this perfectly.

PS Patton Oswalt, I'm sorry but you are hiding something my man. Nobody is that big a Wife Guy

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...