Friday, November 6, 2026

Ash is Purest White (2018)

Jia Zhangke’s movie probes its underworld characters so deeply that it gets past their individuality to the collective philosophy, the jianghu, that binds them all. The way a cheap thrill turns into a necessity of life when there’s nothing to replace it with. The way coming from somewhere shitty makes contemplating somewhere better a reason to lash out, because what, is this not good enough for you? And the hovering monolith of urban renewal, which will never come for the “people like us” whom star-crossed lovers Bin and Xiao wonder if they’re really part of. The political world might as well be weather patterns for this movie's underclass: unaccountable, inscrutable, yet an elemental, life-destroying force all the same.

The best American version of this isn’t a movie but the Wire- but where the Wire’s literary to the core, Jia goes past even poesy to land in the truly musical. John Hughes couldn’t match this guy for the sheer tearjerking impact of his music and dance sequences. Like a virtuoso guitarist with a pedalboard full of effects, Jia doesn’t leave his movie’s tone textures to chance, shooting his multi-decade saga with era-appropriate film stocks and equipment, updating as he goes along, but keeping something most filmmakers would absolutely cockslap you in the face with so subtle that you might not notice it at all. The location scouts on this movie, in finding landscapes that play perfectly as China's Rust Belt pre-, during-, and post-urban development boom, might have done better at that job than anyone else has, ever?

Time and its passing is the real point of this whole thing. In the talk with Jia that followed my screening, the director emphasized that time is what this movie is all about. We live in a world that is rapidly fragmenting, he said, and it’s important now more than ever to take the long view rather than focusing on tiny details. He’s right, of course: depict enough of time’s passage and you’ll always get a story…. and what a story this one is. I haven’t seen a better film this year.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...