Splitting the difference between zero and five stars on this one- rating art is always dumb as hell, but it's especially meaningless with a project like this. As a narrative movie this is a complete and utter mess, totally incoherent without the audience bringing in a whole boatload of pre-existing knowledge. Lucky for all involved, that knowledge involves the doings of the world's richest and most influential people, broadcast live 24/7 over the past decade, so you'd have to be living under a rent-controlled rock to not know what's going on here.
In one of Nico Ballesteros's documentary's three truly interesting moments, early on, Kanye muses vaguely about living his life like it's a movie. Not a unique sentiment from a rapper, but the way he draws it out is, imagining how a movie about our day and age made 200 years from now might portray us, how the future's blindness to the microtrends of the moment possesses an authority that we, pinned in time, never have. Ballesteros including this monologue in his film feels an awful lot like a disclaimer: having shot a reported 3000+ hours of footage for this project and spent a year editing it (a process put onscreen in a brief epilogue segment), the filmmaker makes it impossible not to wonder what other, better unmade movies this one could have been. A couple guys in their 20s with no previous credits taking charge of an archive with the amount of sociopolitical significance this one has feels both unfair and perfectly of our brainrotted times; an open source archive of this footage for the public and any interested Real Directors to endlessly re-edit into their own Kanye/Trump/early years of American fascism docs seems both like a pipe dream and something that a guy like Kanye might actually allow.
Buuut, this is what we got for now, and for all its flaws it's still fascinating, joining the Jinx and Telemarketers and the Qanon documentary as an instant Primary Historical Source. If those three respectively touched on the worlds of the super-rich, the underclass, and the bourgeois in the last days of the American empire, this one mines the richest loam, the worlds of celebrity and politics as they merge with one another in a process akin to the last 60 seconds of Melancholia. One of the movie's other actually interesting moments- also toward the beginning before its subject completely gives way to his mental illness- shows Kanye visiting his old neighborhood in Chicago and meeting a former acquaintance of his late mother, who embraces him fiercely and tells him never to forget where the fuck he came from.
Of course he instantly proceeds to do just that, and the grueling next hour and a half of the movie features approximately zero humans who aren't employed by Kanye, worshipping him in adulation, or living at a comparable level of wealth and power. The American project failed because Americans were incapable of prioritizing government by and for the people over individual exceptionalism: we as a culture worship those who forcibly elevate themselves above us, rather than subordinating themselves to us in service. This paradigm made Trump inevitable, and if he's the ultimate culmination of our culture, Kanye might be the figure in whom the greatest number of its strands are braided. His schizo riffs late in the movie about "destroying labels" by declaring that he's black and white, straight and gay, Jewish and antisemitic don't really articulate this (or any) idea, but they do gesture toward a truth of his experience, and his alone: a figure who combines Kanye's total access to the halls of power and capital with his relentless, all-consuming artistic curiosity really can encompass Whitmanesque multitudes us ordinary mortals couldn't dream of. Zero other humans' documentaries are gonna have both Charlie Kirk and Diddy jumpscares in the first 15 minutes of their runtimes!
I came into this movie hoping and half-expecting it to confirm the Kanye-got-MKUltra'ed theory that I see around a lot and sort of believe myself; if any of ya'll got that out of this I'm jealous, but the story it told me was infinitely more banal. Famous Artists balance their fundamentally internal, individual, self-directed Art quests with the surveilled, socially dictated dance of Fame, and one's got to win out eventually. Same for the battle between glorifying oneself and serving one's audience through one's art. With Kanye, and American culture in general, self and celebrity beat audience and art. A guy whose work once both rode and predicted the zeitgeist was canny enough to see that Making Stuff has become secondary to Posting in Trump's America, and set out to conquer that sphere with the same outrageousness he used to conquer pop culture. Think what you will about Kanye, but you can't deny "Heil Hitler" has a lot to say about where our culture's headed- I, like most of you probably, had no trouble ignoring the song, but I can't not know the meme- and I don't get to have a choice about living in the Nazi USA.
Like I said earlier though, I'm bringing most of this in from outside the movie- from the real world, where time goes on and we don't end balanced over the precipice but plunge down into hell. Trump gets re-elected, Kanye goes full Nazi, World War 3's opening skirmishes are fought. The movie ends somewhere in early 2024, before the process it details is complete. Who knows why- maybe they figured they better get some money out of it now before Kanye became a completely unsellable pariah (yeah right)- but like this starts midstream with your life as the Previously On narration, it ends with your life as the Next Time On stinger too. Ballesteros isn't a great filmmaker, but that's forgivable: what isn't is how he, or Kanye, or somebody up the chain, lost the courage of their convictions in making this and left the story it tells- one everybody knows the gruesome ending of- unfinished.
The last legitimately interesting moment in this is a brief shot toward the end of Kanye walking down a mirrored hallway in the Yeezy headquarters as he begins the brainstorming session that would result in selling swastika t-shirts on his website. A pigeon has somehow gotten into the building, and flutters around attacking its reflection as a famous celebrity strides past it. Tiring, it wilts to the ground and simply looks into the mirror quizzically. Ballesteros, showing a real filmmaker's instincts for a brief moment, swings the camera down to focus on it for a few seconds. Then he hurries to catch up with the man who's paying him.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Detective (1968)
Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...
-
- PSYCHOPATH VS. AUTIST: The Final Battle For The Vanishing Mind Of America (Slowed/Bass Boosted) - ELIZABETH HOLMES is guilty as sin:...
-
In both this and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - the two good Batman Animated movies - the Joker creates a queer-coded chosen family ...
-
“You’ve spoken so often of ending it all. I can’t understand why this should be so difficult for you.” An understated, plainspoken movi...

No comments:
Post a Comment