Friday, November 6, 2026

One Battle After Another (2025)

I’m not quite as high on this as some of ya’ll, but maybe that’s because the first 45 minutes sets such a towering standard- I wasn’t aware PTA had something so visceral in his bag! Is the drone shot that closes out Perfidia’s life of crime an homage to Michael Bay ferchrissakes? It’s rare for something so purely entertaining to function so perfectly as political art- my lord, was this shot yesterday? Is this waiting for me outside my door this morning because I made a joke about Charlie Kirk’s kids on Letterbox™️ last week?

Don’t get me wrong, the second and third acts are good too, but the movie’s very clearly leaking air all through them. Leo funny, Sean Penn might as well clear his mantle for the Oscar now, the ICE raid sequence is a banger (and ends with a fucking Mary Poppins homage!!!), and whether or not she got the job because she has a Thomas Pynchon character-ass name, Chase Infiniti is fantastic.

But this is way too long and feels labored when it should be light- says the guy whose favorite movie is Andrei Rublev. The score comes in for a lot of the blame- tense, repeating piano figures are asked to shoulder way more drama than they’re built for. I’m willing to forgive the endless, aimless cross-cutting between close-ups when it finally pays off spectacularly in the car chase sequence (is that a Wayne Thiebaud reference in that one wide shot??). But my real issue is that PTA made this movie without a style to it, furiously channel-surfing between pastiches of Kubrick, Scorsese, and Tarantino, who I like as much as the next guy but is clearly a lesser artist. On top of that, the quotations in this are endless- just off the top of my head there’s shots in this that are ganked from Texas Chainsaw, Mad Max, The Searchers, X-Men Apocalypse , Heat, No Country for Old Men, the aforementioned Mary Poppins… and I know I’m forgetting some. It’s exhausting to be constantly reminded of better movies when I’m trying to enjoy this one!

I don’t think PTA is doing this on accident- he’s more than capable of mounting a style, and that kind of Reference Retromania isn’t too far from the feel of reading Pynchon, in its way… but it feels a lot more like scrolling on phone to me, random tidbits blasted out at you in quest of that dry “huh!” half-chuckle of passive recognition, and that’s the exact thing I go to the movies to avoid!

Still a good time at the theatah and Leo’s character being functionally indistinguishable from my own father cut some ice with me for sure. I ain’t made of stone

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Detective (1968)

Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...