When it's all said and done, we're gonna be looking at Kathryn Bigelow as the Leni Riefenstahl of American fascism. I first saw this on opening night at a sold-out show in NYC, stoned to the bone with my brother- seems absurd now, but it was less than 6 months since the Batman shooting in Colorado, and given the hype and context behind this movie, there were armed cops stationed all throughout the theater lobby and screening room just in case somebody decided to start popping off. The 9/11 audio montage opening sent the audience into a hysteria that never let up- I can't remember being in a movie where the atmosphere was thicker than that one. Looking back, I can't really say with any conviction that I wouldn't have been hype as fuck at a Nuremberg rally: the madness of that crowd did its work on me, and I walked out with my critical faculties completely overmastered by the sturm and drang of what I'd been watching. Was there meaning to the thing beyond its power? I didn't know!
Talking to factualopinion about it the next day, he gave a critical take that's spent the intervening years functioning as my own, calling this the movie that presents the most overwhelming use of force ever filmed. I think he was and is correct, but looking at it now, the sense of awe that use of force with is framed with is truly disturbing.
Kathryn Bigelow was probably always right wing in the surreptitious way all pink-pussy-hat liberal white women are, but once she embedded in the Middle East with Department of Defense handlers and CIA asset Mark Boal to make the Hurt Locker, and then returned for another tour of duty with even more military-industrial complex oversight and "advisors" to shoot this, she was pretty much fucked. You can only spend so much time within an institution before its outlook rubs off on you, and given Bigelow's career-long fascination with violence and power, it's no surprise she found her muse in the War on Terror. I think this movie is probably a lot more autobiographical than it seems on the surface: Jessica Chastain is a mask for Bigelow herself, a willing convert to the law of the gun who finds her calling in the US military's transformation of the desert into a killing field.
Where the Hurt Locker is "merely" a racist movie, Zero Dark Thirty functions more or less as a wholesale endorsement of US military intelligence's approach to the Middle East. Torture is mean but it gets results, there's no ideology to autonomous resistance beyond "want(ing) to keel Amereecans," and if we don't watch the monkeys in the cages carefully they'll steal all our ice cream! It's being extremely generous to Bigelow to read this movie as a treatise on the way war has dehumanized all its robotic "characters"- next to the dirt-stained, acne-scarred, scraggle-bearded brown people Bigelow dug up to play the bad guys, Coach Taylor and his rugged phalanx of Australian-for-some-reason jock actors look for all the world like a model of the stiff-upper-lip pragmatism and self-mastery that supposedly won the West dominion of the globe.
By removing ideology, politics, and morality from their movie, Boal and Bigelow render the Middle East as a perpetual war zone outside of time or history, a Wile E. Coyote landscape where nothing can change and only might can make right, and thus the greatest show of force ever filmed being brought to bear on a frail old man and his family is transmuted into a heroic action that will echo in myth and legend for eternity. Fascist aesthetics 101, and if you don't recognize it as such you're getting snowed. Fuck this Nazi shit.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Detective (1968)
Because I am nothing if not a cliche white guy in his mid-30s, I've been listening to little but Frank Sinatra's late-career hipst...
-
- PSYCHOPATH VS. AUTIST: The Final Battle For The Vanishing Mind Of America (Slowed/Bass Boosted) - ELIZABETH HOLMES is guilty as sin:...
-
In both this and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - the two good Batman Animated movies - the Joker creates a queer-coded chosen family ...
-
“You’ve spoken so often of ending it all. I can’t understand why this should be so difficult for you.” An understated, plainspoken movi...

No comments:
Post a Comment